Peony in Love – Book Review

They had formed a sisterhood of friendship and writing, and then they built an intellectual and emotional community of women throughout the country through reading. In looking for solace, dignity, and recognition, they brought their quest to other women who still lived behind locked gates or were being pushed back inside by the Manchus. -From Peony in Love, page 206-

In 1644, the Ming Dynasty fell and was replaced by the Manchu Qing Dynasty. China reeled from this reorganization for nearly 30 years – women especially were impacted. This was a time in history defined by the “lovesick” maidens and the publication of thousands of poems and writings by women.

Lisa See has set her latest novel – Peony in Love– during this tumultuous time in China’s history. Peony, a sixteen year old girl, is preparing to “marry out.”. As tradition demands, she is not allowed to meet the man who will become her husband. Peony dreams of the ideal husband, and wishes for true love. She becomes enraptured by The Peony Pavilion, an opera  which speaks of the deep emotions and sentimental love called qing. It is interesting to note that this opera actually existed and was ultimately banned in China for its political and lascivious leanings. As the story unfolds, the reader travels with Peony through an exotic time and place as she discovers the true meaning of love, and unravels the mystery of the afterworld. Touching on subjects as vast as “mother love” and women’s rights, See creates a lyrical novel which provides insight into a culture filled with symbolism, tradition, and superstition.

At times, See becomes heavy handed with her characters imbuing them with emotion and importance which felt sappy and unreal. See spins a tale which forces the reader to suspend belief and simply float along with the story. The ending was a bit too predictable and the conflict sewn up too neatly.

In comparison to her blockbuster novel – Snow Flower and the Secret Fan – See has fallen short of a masterpiece.

Despite these flaws, Peony in Love is an solid and enjoyable novel which informs the reader of the intricacies of Chinese history during the Qing Dynasty when women, for the first time, were allowed to experience the joy of writing and having their works published.


Please follow and like the blue thistle


Skip to comment form

    • Anonymous on June 22, 2007 at 20:30

    I have been eagerly awaiting your review of this one, Wendy. It’s one I have been looking forward to reading since I first heard she’d published a new book. I’m sorry to hear it doesn’t quite live up to Snow Flower, but I suppose not every book can. 🙂 Great review!

    • Anonymous on June 23, 2007 at 13:14

    It’s worth the read, WendyCat – even though it doesn’t live up to Snow Flower (in my opinion!). I’ll look forward to seeing your review of this book when it comes out 🙂

    • Anonymous on June 24, 2007 at 07:45

    Hi, Wendy!
    I am reading this one at the moment and I do share your opinion that although it is a good novel it can’t quite hold a candle to “Snowflower”. Thank you for the review, I might be prompted to chat more with you about it once I have finished reading the book.

    • Anonymous on June 24, 2007 at 07:46

    Sorry, that was from Lotus of LotusReads! 🙂

    • Anonymous on June 24, 2007 at 10:45

    Thanks for your comments, Lotus! I will be interested to see how the majority of readers feel about this book – Snow Flower was so wonderful, that See would have a hard time matching it – my opinion on Peony is impacted by how much I loved Snow Flower! Do come back and let me know your final thoughts when you are done with the book!

    • Anonymous on July 4, 2007 at 21:32

    I LOVED Snow Flower. I might consider this one for the 2nds Challenge.

    • Anonymous on July 6, 2007 at 14:32

    I’m looking forward to reading your review on this one, Michelle 🙂

    • Anonymous on July 29, 2007 at 12:39

    Wendy, we have a problem. The link you provided for the Alias Grace review took me to this review for Peony in Love. Help! I’ll search for it, but if I don’t find it, would you please try again? Thanks.

Comments have been disabled.

Social media & sharing icons powered by UltimatelySocial

Enjoy this blog? Please spread the word :)