September 2007
« Aug   Oct »

My Material Is Copyrighted

Site Meter

Sites Where I Review Books

LibraryThing Early Reviewers




Winner Best Literary Fiction Blog - 2008
Shortlisted for Best Literary Fiction Blog - 2009, 2010
Longlisted for Best Literary Fiction Blog - 2011 Shortlisted Best Written Book Blog - 2010

The Echo Maker – Book Review

All the humans revered Crane, the great orator. Where cranes gathered, their speech carried miles. The Aztecs called themselves the Crane People. One of the Anishinaabe clans  was named the Cranes – Ajijak or Businassee – the Echo Makers. The Cranes were leaders, voices that called all people together. Crow and Cheyenne carved cranes’ leg bones into hollow flutes, echoing the echo maker. -From The Echo Maker, page 181-

Richard Power’s novel – The Echo Maker – is a Pulitzer Prize finalist and winner of the National Book Award. Beneath a simple story lies complex questions about self and memory. How does memory define who we are? Is our sense of self and the larger world just a series of synapses and neurons firing or is it something bigger?

The novel begins with a horrific car accident along the Platte River during the annual crane migration. Mark Schulter survives the crash, but is left with a rare and devastating brain injury called Capgras Syndrome. Believing his sister, Karin, is really an imposter who is pretending to be his sister, Mark’s recovery from his injuries takes the reader along a winding path of self-discovery, misidentification, conspiracies, and the complex and sometimes fragile nature of relationships. Powers constructs the novel around four major characters: Mark Schulter, his sister Karin, a renowned scientist named Gerald Weber, and Barbara Gillespie – a nursing home aide who is surrounded by mystery. It is not only Mark who struggles with his identity. Karin, a woman who has tried unsuccessfully to shed her past, finds herself searching to re-define it.

When Mark was himself again, she would restart them both. She’d get him on his feet, listen to him, help him find what he need to be. And this time she’d take him away with her, someplace reasonable. -From The Echo Maker, page 26-

Making herself over, personality du jour. Imagination, even memory, all too ready to accommodate her, whoever her is. Anything for a scratch behind the ears. Scratch from anyone. She is nothing. No one. Worse than no one. Blank at the core. She must change her life. From the mess of her fouled nest, salvage something. Anything. -From The Echo Maker, page 407-

Gerald Weber is shocked to discover that perhaps he is only defined by the way others perceive him – that perhaps his life’s work is no more than a critics review: He’d let his critics convince him. Something had eroded, the core pleasure in his accomplishment. – From The Echo Maker, page 315-

This novel is meant to be read slowly – it is a thoughtful novel, and one that is challenging on an intellectual level. Powers deftly constructs a story which questions the very core of who we are and how self is defined – a fascinating treatise about what makes us human. The backdrop of Nebraska and its incredible crane migration – an astounding feat of migratory memory and ritual – is a fitting symbol of the novel’s thematic content.  With a surprising twist at the end, the novel is ultimately a satisfying read.



  1. Anonymous Anonymous
    September 6, 2007    

    I loved how Karin actually got a little jealous of the sister Mark thought he’d lost because she didn’t see herself that way at all. This was a really great book. Good review.

  2. Anonymous Anonymous
    September 6, 2007    

    I just finished this one as well. This is a thoughtful review, Wendy. I loved this book and all the questions it posed.

  3. Anonymous Anonymous
    September 6, 2007    

    Thanks for visiting my blog and linking me to your review!

  4. Anonymous Anonymous
    September 6, 2007    

    Verbivore and Kookie: Thanks for the kudos on this review. I thought this was a fascinating book on a few levels. Glad you both enjoyed it as well.
    Ruth: Thanks for visiting!

  5. Anonymous Anonymous
    September 10, 2007    

    I knew when I saw your post that this book was familiar. It sounded good, and I finally figured out why it sounded familiar. I’d seen it on the Powell’s Staff Picks list when I was looking for possibilities for the Themed Reading Challenge. Cool – I now have my first official pick for that challenge 🙂 I was already considering it, but your review clinched it.

  6. Anonymous Anonymous
    September 12, 2007    

    Suzi, glad to help you pick books 🙂 Hope you will enjoy it as much as I did.

  7. Anonymous Anonymous
    September 28, 2007    

    I have this on my Book Awards list, and have really been looking forward to it. Even more so, now.

  8. Anonymous Anonymous
    September 30, 2007    

    Will look forward to your review, Debi!

follow us in feedly

Publishers and Authors…

I am no longer accepting review copies of books except for very rare exceptions. Thank you.


Rating System

= Excellent
= Good/Very Good
= Okay read
= Not recommended
= Ugh! Don't waste your time.


Bee Groups


Book Giveaways

None Current.