caribousmom Rotating Header Image

Posts from ‘November, 2007’

The Library Window – Book review

“The question is,” said my aunt, “if it is a real window with glass in it, or if it is merely painted, or if it once was a window, and has been built up. And the oftener people look at it, the less they are able to say.” -From The Library Window-

Margaret Oliphant published this Gothic novella in 1896. I found it through Gaslight – an internet discussion group – which provided the book as an e-text.

The story takes place in Scotland and is narrated by a young girl who is visiting her Aunt Mary. Bored by Mary’s tea parties with her elderly friends, the narrator spends much of her time tucked away in a large window with her sewing and books while she idly listens to the older people talk. When the conversation turns to a window across the street, the narrator’s imagination is inflamed.

Oliphant carries the reader forward with the simple, yet mysterious plot. The reader, along with the narrator begins to ask herself what is real and what is not.

Aunt Mary’s old ladies came and went day after day while June went on. I was to go back in July, and I felt that I should be very unwilling indeed to leave until I had quite cleared up – as I was indeed in the way of doing – the mystery of that window which changed so strangely and appeared quite a different thing, not only to different people, but to the same eyes at different times. – From The Library Window-

The story is not just pure mystery, but stimulates some compelling questions about how we see the world – and if our ‘vision’ declines with age. How much of what we see do we interpret correctly?

It is always interesting to have a glimpse like this of an unknown life – to see so much and yet know so little. -From The Library Window-

A classic tale which reads quickly, I would recommend this book for those readers who enjoy late 19th century literature and gothic mysteries.

To read more about Margaret Oliphant and for links to her vast works, check out this wonderful site.

Book Blogging Out of Control

My book blogging has gotten out of control. I’m obsessed. I’m in need of intervention. I – just – cannot – stop.

A list of the book related blogs I own (besides this one):

1. The Lists – Books for the Obsessive Reader

A place to note all those wonderful lists of prize winners, most notable books, influential book written by women, Oprah’s picks. Every time I find a list, I feel compelled to copy it down and see how many books I can cross off of it. This blog feeds that compulsion. I’ve provided links to my reviews.

2. A Novel Challenge

Links and descriptions of all the reading challenges to be found around the blog-o-sphere. Addicted to reading challenges? This is the place to come!

3. Notable Books

An off shoot of The New York Times Most Notable blog (see below). This one is a group blog for those readers wanting to read books from the most notable lists – including the New York Times. Participants are encouraged to create their own personalized challenges from the books listed here…and then post their reviews to the blog. Why not join us?

4. New York Times Notable Book Challenge

Created by Ariel (and co-administrated by me) as a place where readers can post reviews and progress on the New York Times Most Notable Book Challenge, this is a great place to read reviews and participate in discussion about some of the best books of 2005/2006. Readers wanting to read from the New York Times Most Notable List for THIS year should stop by Notable Books (above).

A list of book challenge blogs where I contribute:

1. Banned Books

Owned by Bonnie at Bonnie Reviews Books AND Bonnie’s Books, this blog is a place to read reviews of banned books.

2. 888

Owned by Michelle at One More Chapter, this blog is for readers participating in the Eight Books in Eight Categories in 2008 Challenge (also known as the Triple 8 Challenge!). Readers are posting interesting categories and listing their books here with links to their reviews.

3. Book Awards Reading Challenge

Also owned by Michelle at One More Chapter, this blog is for readers participating in the Book Awards Challenge. Michelle has provided links to lists of winners of most of the book awards. Participants are reading from those lists and posting their reviews here.

4. The Pulitzer Project

Once again, Michelle has come up with a fabulous challenge blog. There is no time limit for readers wishing to read all the winners of the prestigious Pulitzer Prize. This blog provides a place for participants in the challenge to post their progress and reviews.

5. Something About Me Reading Challenge

Hosted by Lisa at Breaking the Fourth Wall, this blog is for readers participating in the highly original “Something About Me” challenge. Here you will find wonderful books and reviews recommended by readers – enough to keep you busy through most of the next few years if you decide to read them all!

6. The Complete Booker

My bookie-soul-mate Laura at Musings hosts this blog – a place for readers who want to read all the Booker Prize winners. Contributors to the blog post their progress and book reviews and cheer each other on in this no time limit challenge.

7. Unread Authors

Ariel (aka Por of Tor) at Sycorax Pine is the owner of this reading challenge blog which encourages participants to read new-to-me authors. Reviews and progress reports of participants can be found on this blog.

8. In Their Shoes Reading Challenge

Vasilly at 1330V owns this challenge blog. Due to begin January 1, 2008, this challenge requires participants to read books that are either a memoir, autobiography, or biography. Contributors to the blog will be posting their reviews of the books they read here.

9.  Dystopian Challenge

Lisa at Books.Lists.Life.Too has been hosting a challenge to read books from the Dystopian genre. This blog is where you can find reviews of all the participants. I’m on my last book for this challenge which ends November 6th!

10. Read The Nobels

Aloi Reads is owner of this blog which celebrates the Nobel Winners. Contributors to the blog have challenged themselves to read all of the Nobel Laureates. There is no time limit. Reviews of the work of these acclaimed writers can be found on this blog.

11. Index Librorum Liberorum

Imani from The Books of My Numberless Dreams has dreamt up a fabulous challenge. Contributors to this blog have challenged themselves to read from the list of prohibited books officially catalogued and promulgated by the Roman Catholic Church under the leadership of Pope Paul IV in 1559. Challenge participants will be posting their progress and reviews on this blog.

12. Russian Reading Challenge 2008

Hosted by Sharon from Ex Libris, the Russian Reading Challenge begins in January 2008. This blog is a place for challenge participants to keep track of their progress, post reviews and engage in discussion about some of the best literature (both fiction and non fiction) about Russia or written by Russian authors.

As if all these blogs were not enough, I am also the owner of two Yahoo book groups:

Banned Books – where readers read and discuss one book a month which has either been banned or challenged OR has been written by a banned or challenged author.

A Novel Challenge – where members support, encourage and enable other readers in their addiction to reading challenges.

I also belong to several other Yahoo book groups, too numerous to list here.

I would like to say I’m drawing a line in the sand…that I will refrain from joining more challenges, blogs and book groups. But, I know that no matter how many promises I make to myself…I-just-cannot-stop.

Veronika Decides To Die – Book Review

On November 11, 1997, Veronika decided that the moment to kill herself had – at last! – arrived. She carefully cleaned the room that she rented in a convent, turned off the heat, brushed her teeth, and lay down. - From Veronika Decides to Die, page 1-

Simply written with prose that is almost dreamlike in its quality, Veronika Decides to Die explores life in the face of death, the meaning of insanity, and the importance of following one’s dreams.

Veronika, a young woman, finds herself in a mental institution in Slovenia after a failed suicide attempt. Told she has only days to live because of the overdose’s damage to her heart, Veronika begins to re-evaluate her life. The characters Veronika meets provide the catalyst for her self-reflection: Zedka, the depressed housewife; Mari, the lawyer who gave up her dreams for panic attacks; and Eduard, a schizophrenic artist who has spent his life denying love. Dr. Igor, the administrator of the mental hospital plays a pivotal role in this philosophical novel and his  theories of insanity are used  to question the idea of normalcy.

“I’m trying to study so-called normal human behavior. A lot of doctors before me have done similar studies and reached the conclusion that normality is merely a matter of consensus; that is, a lot of people think something is right, and so that thing becomes right.” -From Veronika Decides to Die, page 166-


While I was reading this book, I began to think about the children and adults with Autism who I have had the privilege of working with…at a seminar several years ago a Speech Pathologist told the story of a young boy with Autism. Whenever he would flap his hands around his face,  the boy’s mother would caution him, “Stop that. Don’t you want to be normal?” And the boy would agree, yes normalcy was what he wanted. One day the Speech Pathologist asked the boy, “Do you know what normal is?” And the boy confidently replied, “Sure. It’s a setting on the dryer.”  I laughed when I heard this story because it was an example of how words like ‘normal’ only have meaning within the context of an individual’s unique experience. Paulo Coelho makes this same argument in Veronika Decides to Die. Sanity is only defined by universal experiences – those individuals who are different or unique or view the world solely from their own perspective are often labeled “not normal” or “crazy.”

Coelho’s message in this novel seems to be one of following one’s dreams, going against the norm, living life to its fullest. As the character Mari explains:

“When I was still a young lawyer, I read some poems by an English poet, and something he said impressed me greatly: ‘Be like the fountain that overflows, not like the cistern that merely contains.’ -From Veronika Decides to Die, page 198-

As each character comes face to face with his or her own mortality, they are forced to look back on their lives and explore their failed dreams. They also ponder God and faith.

God was there, and yet people believed they still had to go on looking, because it seemed too simple to accept that life was an act of faith. -From Veronika Decides to Die, page 149-


This is the second Paulo Coelho novel I have read. Coelho has a unique voice and style – philosophical and dreamlike. His stories are written like fables, with messages about life, God and faith as the over-riding themes. I enjoyed Veronika Decides to Die because it made me think of my own dreams and life path.

Recommended.

Middlesex – Book Review

I feel a direct line extending from that girl with her knees steepled beneath the hotel blankets to this person writing now in an Aeron chair. Hers  was the duty to live out a mythical life in the actual world, mine to tell about it now. -From Middlesex, page 424-

Jeffrey Eugenides Pulitzer Prize winning masterpiece, Middlesex, is a rich family saga spanning three generations and takes the reader from Greece to Detroit on a whirlwind ride of rich, original language and spot on characterization. The story of Calliope Stephanides – an American born intersex individual with strong Greek heritage – is narrated by Cal…Calliope’s adult male counterpart.

Middlesex is a tragic story which is comically portrayed using Greek mythology. Eugenides is a talented writer – his vivid descriptions are filled with the lush sensations of life. The characters who people this wonderful novel are fully developed; their flaws and imperfections revealed even through the names they are given: The Object (Calliope’s teenage love interest), Chapter Eleven (Cal’s brother), and a vast array of other characters based on mythical stories.  Even the title of the book is steeped in symbolism.

Middlesex! Did anybody ever live in a house as strange? As sci-fi? As futuristic and outdated at the same time? A house that was more like communism, better in theory than reality? -From Middlesex, page 258-


The novel is essentially two stories: the history of a Greek family who carries a recessive gene; and the coming of age story of the main character – Calliope. At times it was easy to forget that this huge novel was written by a man. Eugenides wonderful insight into the thoughts of an awkward, self-conscious teenage girl is finely illustrated in this scene in the locker room after a field hockey game:

In front of me girls were entering and exiting the showers. The flashes of nakedness were like shouts going off. A year or so earlier these same girls had been porcelain figurines, gingerly dipping their toes into the disinfectant basin at the public pool. Now they were magnificent creatures. Moving through the humid air, I felt like a snorkeler. On I came, kicking my heavy, padded legs and gaping through the goalie mask at the fantastic underwater life all around me. Sea anemones sprouted from between my classmates’ legs. They came in all colors, black, brown, electric yellow, vivid red. higher up, their breasts bobbed like jellyfish, softly pulsing, tipped with stinging pink. Everything was waving int he current, feeding on microscopic plankton, growing bigger by the minute. The shy, plump girls were like sea lions, lurking in the depths. -From Middlesex, page 297-


The novel is an exploration of immigration and the split loyalties that immigrants face. Eugenides parallels this theme with that of identity in general using the pain of adolescence and the confusion of sexual identity as spring boards to delve into the human psyche.

Middlesex is a vividly imaginative novel – epic in its scope and sensitively wrought. It is well deserving of the Pulitzer Prize.

Highly recommended.