Shanghai Girls – Book Review

So often we’re told that women’s stories are unimportant. After all, what does it matter what happens in the main room, in the kitchen, or in the bedroom? Who cares about the relationships between mother, daughter, and sister? A baby’s illness, the sorrows and pains of childbirth, keeping the family together during war, poverty, or even in the best of days are considered small and insignificant compared with the stories of men, who fight against nature to grow their crops, who wage battles to secure their homelands, who struggle to look inward in search of the perfect man. We’re told that men are strong and brave, but I think women know how to endure, accept defeat, and bear physical and mental agony much better than men. – from Shanghai Girls, page 228 –

Lisa See’s latest novel, Shanghai Girls, is a story of a family…but mostly it is a story about two women, specifically two sisters. May and Pearl are living in Shanghai in 1937. They are “beautiful girls” – born into wealth with all the privileges that entails. But when their father gambles away their life savings, both girls are sold into marriage to pay off the debt. Forced to marry two Chinese boys who currently live in Los Angeles, May and Pearl still hope to remain in Shanghai, working as beautiful girls and living their lives unchanged. Within weeks, however, the Japanese invade China and the girls flee their home to find passage on a ship to San Francisco. What follows is a journey marked by fear, violence, and uncertainty. When the shores of America are finally reached, Pearl and May must get through the labyrinth of immigration before they finally are reunited with their husbands in Southern California. But life is not what they expected.

What’s the first impression you have of a new place? Is it the first meal you eat? The first time you have an ice cream cone? The first person you meet? The first night you spend in your new bed in your new home? The first broken promise? The first time you realize that no one cares about you as anything other than the potential bearer of sons? The knowledge that your neighbors are so poor that they put only a dollar in your lai see, as if that were enough to give a woman a secret treasure to last a lifetime? The recognition that your father-in-law, a man born in this country, has been so isolated in Chinatowns throughout his life that he speaks the most pathetic English ever? The moment you understand that everything you’d come to believe about your in-laws’ class, standing, prosperity, and fortune is as wrong as everything you thought about your natal family’s status and wealth? – from Shanghai Girls, page 135 –

See’s novel takes the reader from the lavish streets of Shanghai to the isolation of immigration services on Angel Island in San Francisco, to the hectic streets of Chinatown in Los Angeles; and spans 20 years of American history and turmoil. Narrated in the distinct voice of Pearl, the eldest sister, the story explores a woman’s role in a traditional Chinese family, the discrimination leveled against Chinese immigrants in the United States during the 40s and 50s, and the relationship between two sisters. Ultimately a secret which Pearl and May keep throughout their lives has far reaching repercussions which neither young woman could possibly have imagined.

As in her previous novels, See develops memorable characters and has a firm grip on the historical details which bring to life the Chinese community in California during the mid twentieth century. If there is a fault in the novel, it is in the middle section when Pearl and May settle into their new lives.  Detailed and methodical, the story slows here and becomes a bit plodding at times. See redeems herself during the last fourth of the novel when the tension rises and secrets are revealed which spark conflict between the two sisters. It was during these last pages of the novel where See completely enthralled me.

Readers who have enjoyed See’s previous work will not be disappointed by this latest effort.

Read more reviews through TLC Book Tours.

Read my TLC Book Tour post and enter a contest to WIN THE BOOK (contest runs through January 23, 2010).

FTC Disclosure: I received this book for review from the publisher through TLC Book Tours.

Please follow and like the blue thistle


Skip to comment form

  1. This one sounds just as great as See’s other works. She rarely disappoints! Looks like it would be a great choice for the Women Unbound challenge.

    • Kathy on January 14, 2010 at 06:55

    I haven’t read any of Lisa See’s work, but I’m anxious too. I love book set in Asia and it sounds like her books are top notch. Great review, as always.

    • Amanda on January 14, 2010 at 08:53

    Wonderful review! For some reason I’m just drawn to stories about sisters. I think that particular bond is so strong and can be so complex. I’ve read her book Snow Flower and the Secret Fan and loved it. I’ve been wanting to read more of her novels.

    • Aths on January 14, 2010 at 18:13

    I’ve never read Lisa See, but she is way high up on my authors to read list. I really enjoyed your review of this book and hope I get to read this soon.

    • Susan on January 16, 2010 at 13:29

    Excellent review. I also read and reviewed this incredible book.

    • Anna on January 17, 2010 at 13:46

    Great review! I absolutely loved this book. Serena’s interview with Lisa See says she’s working on the sequel right now. I can’t wait!

    • Teddy on January 17, 2010 at 22:12

    I loved Snowflower and the Secret Fan. This one is on my TBR, so I’m glad you enjoyed it.

    • Wendy on January 18, 2010 at 09:26

    Stephanie: I hadn’t thought of it for Women Unbound…but, yes, I think it would fit that challenge well.

    Kathy: If I had to recommend just one Lisa See book, it would be Snowflower and the Secret Fan…she is definitely a good writer to introduce the reader to the Asian history.

    Amanda: I like novels about sisters too…hope you’ll get a chance to read this one.

    Aths: I’ll look forward to hearing what you think about it.

    Susan: Thanks – I’ll have to get over to your blog and read your review. I’m SO far behind right now in everything!

    Anna: Oh, I didn’t realize there would be a sequel! I’m glad because this book ended with a lot of questions still in my mind. I’d definitely read the sequel!

    Teddy: I hope you’ll enjoy it 🙂

    • Lisamm on January 19, 2010 at 11:13

    Wendy! Sorry I’m late getting over here. What a wonderful review! Your reviews are always so engaging and fun to read. I’m so happy you enjoyed this book (one of my favorites of last year). Thank you so much for all the time you put into reading and reviewing SG. We really appreciate it.

  2. I really enjoyed this novel and didn’t note any of the plodding that you describe. I think I was too absorbed in the lives of Pearl and May by that point.

    • Wendy on January 27, 2010 at 10:57

    Lisa: No need to apologize! Thanks for your comment 🙂

    Serena: Glad you loved the book – I felt a bit impatient with it at times, although I did end up enjoying it. Perhaps it was just the mood I was in when I read it 🙂

  3. I loved her other two books. I’m definitely adding this to my TBR list!

    • Wendy on January 31, 2010 at 10:53

    Sarah: If you loved her previous books, I guarantee you’ll love this one too!

Comments have been disabled.

Social media & sharing icons powered by UltimatelySocial

Enjoy this blog? Please spread the word :)