Darkness, My Old Friend – Book Review

He was a grave robber, waiting for the night watchman to drift off once and for all. Then, and only then, could he dig his fingers into the earth and exhume the truth. – from Darkness, My Old Friend, page 82 –

Jones Cooper has walked away from his job as a police officer and is struggling with his past when a psychic shows up at his door with a chilling prediction.  Eloise Montgomery has been seeing things psychically for years, ever since the car accident that killed her husband and daughter and left her comatose for several days. Eloise and local PI Ray Muldune are teaming up to try to uncover the mystery surrounding a local woman’s disappearance many years earlier. The woman’s son, Michael Holt, is now an adult and wants to find the answers to what happened to his mother – his memory of her last day is full of blank spots that he seems unable to shed any light upon. Fifteen year old Willow Graves and her mystery writer mother, Bethany, have recently moved from New York City, looking for safety and peace in small town life. Willow is angry and confused about her parent’s bitter divorce, and has a tendency to run when things get uncomfortable. All these characters’ lives cross in The Hollows, a tiny town with dark woods and even darker secrets.

Darkness, My Old Friend is Lisa Unger’s latest thriller and a follow up to her last novel, Fragile. Unger assumes some knowledge of her characters, so if you are like me and have not read the prequel to Darkness, My Old Friend, it takes a few pages to be brought up to speed. Even still, I found myself quickly drawn into the lives of the characters. Jones Cooper is clearly the primary character around whom the plot turns. Struggling with his marriage and not sure what to do with his life, he becomes embroiled in the town’s most talked about mystery – that of the disappearance of Marla Holt. Tough, smart and skeptical of anything that cannot be proved, Jones is a likable character. The other characters are carefully fleshed out as Unger writes from multiple points of view in order to reveal their histories and motivations.

I enjoyed Unger’s writing style which reminded me of some of Laura Lippman’s later novels. The plot is drawn from the complexities of the characters’ lives and is actually not really much of a whodunnit (I figured out the “mystery” long before I got to the end of the book) – but, more of an exploration into motivation and the dark side of human nature. Thematically, Unger explores the mother-child relationship, self image, and identity. All the characters are faced with re-examining their past in order to find a balance between personal fulfillment and obligation.

Strengths of the novel include sharp dialogue, believable characters and an interesting psychological study of human behavior. If there is a weakness in the book it is a tendency to wrap the plot up a little too neatly.

Overall, a good read which will appeal to those who enjoy psychological thrillers.


  • Quality of Writing:
  • Plot:
  • Characters:

Overall Rating:

Please follow and like the blue thistle


Skip to comment form

  1. I think, sometimes, with good characters and good dialogue, the plot can fall by the wayside and I won’t care/notice. I also have to say that I’m going to have The Sound of Silence stuck in my head for the rest of the day, now…

  2. I tend to like those mysteries even more when the whodunnit is secondary to character development. This sounds good!

    • Wendy on August 28, 2011 at 07:29

    Pam: I agree – I like the psychological depth that Unger puts into this novel. LOL re: the Sound of Silence – now I’m humming it too 🙂

    Jill: Me too – this is a good read.

  3. I really liked Fragile and expect I’ll like this one too. I don’t mind it when a book is wrapped up neatly.

  4. I don’t usually read a lot of books in this genre, but something about this book sounds interesting to me. I think the themes sound very intriguing, and though I haven’t read any of the other books in this series, I might try this one. I really liked this review, by the way!

    • Wendy on August 29, 2011 at 06:34

    Kathy: I wish I had read Fragile first – I think it would have enhanced the reading experience for me.

    Heather: I hope you’ll enjoy it. I think Unger is much more “literary” in her thrillers than a lot of authors who write in this genre (which is why I think she reminds me of Lippman).

    • Linda on September 10, 2011 at 07:19

    Just finished Darkness and enjoyed it as much as you did. First rate review!

    • Wendy on September 12, 2011 at 13:05

    Linda: So glad you liked the book! Thanks for the nice comment 🙂

Comments have been disabled.

Social media & sharing icons powered by UltimatelySocial

Enjoy this blog? Please spread the word :)